The TBA continues to share resources across communication platforms to help educate Tennessee lawyers about the state's system of indigent representation, which plays a crucial role in ensuring that individuals' right to counsel is provided for. This article highlights the factors that courts may consider in determining to appoint an attorney for a defendant.

December 6, 2024

The "best interest of the child" standard is a cornerstone in legal proceedings affecting minors, prioritizing a child’s safety, well-being and developmental needs, especially in cases concerning neglect, custody and visitation. But how do courts ensure that the child's voice is heard and their needs are fully considered in legal decisions? This is where a Guardian ad Litem (GAL) comes in.

As will be familiar to most in the legal community, a guardian ad Litem is a court-appointed advocate who represents the best interests of a child or vulnerable individual during legal proceedings. GALs are commonly appointed in family law matters, particularly in dependency and neglect proceedings, child custody disputes and juvenile dependency proceedings. Their role is not to represent the child’s wishes directly (unless those wishes align with their best interests), but rather to assess what would serve the child’s long-term welfare. The GAL’s core responsibilities include investigation, reporting and representation, and they act as an independent party in the case, ensuring that the child's welfare is prioritized in court proceedings.

In Tennessee, Supreme Court Rule 40 sets forth guidelines and responsibilities of GALs in juvenile court neglect, abuse and dependency proceedings. The rule also provides factors to be considered when making a determination of the best interest of a child and encourages "consultation with experts when appropriate." Among the factors that a GAL should consider are a child's physical, social and educational needs, as well as the significance of continuity and existing ties to caregivers and community.

In Tennessee, the scope of the GAL’s authority is generally defined by the court at the time of appointment. Tennessee courts may grant GALs significant investigatory powers: interviews with the child, reviewing medical and school records, consulting with mental health professionals and other experts. In some instances, the GAL’s role may be more limited, depending on the circumstances and the judge’s orders.

The significance of a Guardian ad Litem in legal proceedings cannot be overstated. Their role is pivotal in cases involving children, serving as independent advocates for the child’s well-being and providing the court with an objective, child-centered perspective that may not be evident from the perspectives of the parents or other parties involved. In many instances, family law cases can be complex and emotionally charged; a GAL ensures that decisions are made based on the child’s needs, rather than the adult participants’ desires.

Last December, the Tennessee Council of Juvenile and Family Court Judges released a statement in support of efforts to increase compensation for court appointed attorneys in juvenile court, highlighting the challenges courts are facing in finding enough lawyers to take appointed cases.

Guardians ad Litem system ensures that vulnerable children have an advocate who will tirelessly fight for their best interests in the courts. The GAL’s independent voice and thorough investigative work ultimately help ensure that the courts make informed, well-rounded decisions that protect the most vulnerable members of society.

Get Involved

The TBA is looking for your input! Share your questions or topics that you would like to hear about in this series. There are several ways to connect with TBA to share your questions or experiences with indigent representation. Attorneys interested in learning more about TBA's grassroots advocacy efforts can sign up for TBA Grassroots Advocacy Updates, which will highlight related policy content across all of TBA's communication platforms. Attorneys with experience working with clients who are indigent or vulnerable, should complete this survey, which includes specific questions about court appointed representation. Looking for more information? Check out our Indigent Representation Resource page.