TBA Law Blog

TBA Law Blog

Supreme Court Sends Nashville Home Business Law Case Back to Trial Court

Posted by: Kate Prince on Aug 18, 2022

A challenge to Nashville's laws restricting home-based businesses was today sent back to the trial court by the Tennessee Supreme Court. A Nashville music producer and a licensed cosmetologist, both running businesses out of their homes, sued Metro in 2017 after their businesses were found to be in violation of Nashville’s “client prohibition” law, which states that “No clients or patrons may be served on the property.” A trial court ruled in Metro’s favor. While the appeal was pending, Metro Council repealed the client prohibition law, replacing it with a new law allowing home businesses up to six customer visits per day. The Court of Appeals ruled the case moot due to Metro's repeal of the law. On appeal before the Supreme Court, the plaintiffs argued their case was not moot because they were still being harmed by the new law. The high court found the new law did not completely cure the harm claimed by the plaintiffs and that the appellate court could not be sure whether the plaintiffs will suffer ongoing harm. The justices unanimously decided to vacate the previous decisions and send the case back to trial court. Read more from the Administrative Office of the Courts.

Law-Related Blogs AND PODCASTS

Check out other law-related blogs and podcasts generated from the Tennessee legal community or of interest to the Tennessee lawyers.